I think I get the angriest letter award among the several the Times is running December 25 on Wendell Jamieson’s skewering of Bedford Falls. I don’t know how I managed to sound bitter while critiquing cynicism. But I did.
Merry Christmas to you all and blessings in 2009. May 2009 be full of at what is good.
To the Editor:
I wasn’t much of an “It’s a Wonderful Life” fan until I read Wendell Jamieson’s “Wonderful? Sorry, George, It’s a Pitiful, Dreadful Life.”
Mr. Jamieson’s attempt at iconoclasm says so much about what’s wrong with the world. It misses the point of what doing the right thing on a daily basis, instead of the exciting thing in one heroic moment, adds up to in George Bailey’s life, or would add up to in anyone’s life.
A “cooler” nightlife cannot replace the many difficult, selfless choices so many unsung people make on a regular basis. Such a worldview, which allows no room for the redemption that comes with living a good life in a broken world, is not just cynical. It’s morally bankrupt. It does not reflect the reality of the world we live in and what it needs.
[–]
Washington, Dec.20, 2008